Complaint Details

Status	:	Closed
Complaint No	:	0020814/2014
Category	:	Hospitality
Date	:	28-04-2014
Subject Line	:	Fraud in Medical Bill, Fake Invoice Provided, Over Charged for Services
Complainant	:	Sagar Shinde
Address	:	T/B/S 3, Room No 26, CGS Colony, Ghatkopar West
Complainee	:	Vardan Nursing Home Pvt Ltd
Address	:	Vardan Nursing Home Pvt Ltd, 65 – Jawahar Nagar, Opposite Prakash Hotel, Goregaon West, Mumbai.

Complaint Details
My name is Sagar Shinde and I reside in Ghatkopar West, Mumbai.

On 30th April 2013, I had undergone a cosmetic liposuction surgery at Vardan Nursing Home Pvt Ltd, Goregaon West. I came to know about this hospital through their website www.alluremedspa.in


During the pre-surgery consultation, the cosmetic surgeon, Dr. Milan Doshi had quoted me Rs. 1,05,000/- for the surgery excluding the Service Tax. The consulting fees were Rs. 1,000/- which would be reimbursed if I opted for the surgery.


I paid Rs. 1,05,000/- (Base Surgery Fees) + Rs. 12,978/- (Service Tax @ 12.36% on Rs. 1,05,000/-) = Rs. 1,17,978/- (Base Fees + Service Tax) and an additional Rs. 2,360/- (2% of Rs. 1,17,978/- as the mode of payment was credit card)


So, in all, I paid Rs. 1,20,338/- towards the hospital fees.


After the bill payment, it was discussed that the final bill will be sent to you by courier.


After repeated requests over the phone, they sent me a bill (Invoice No. May0004 Dated 2-May-2013) amounting to Rs. 61,106/- and the Service Tax was computed only on Rs. 51,100/- the details of which are as under –

Service Tax = Rs. 6,132/-

Education Cess = Rs. 122.64

Secondary and Higher Education Cess = Rs. 61.32


After I questioned them the authenticity of the bill, they agreed to send me a revised bill (Invoice No. May0004 Dated 2-May-2013) amounting to Rs. 1,20,338/- and the Service Tax was computed on Rs. 93,100/- the details of which are as under –

Service Tax = Rs. 11,172/-

Education Cess = Rs. 223.44

Secondary and Higher Education Cess = Rs. 111.72


I highly doubt the authenticity of the revised invoice and decided to discuss this issue with a Chartered Accountant. I believe that I have been duped to the tune of Rs. 60,000/-. The Chartered Accountant asked me to get a copy of his Service Tax for CENVAT credit purpose.

It has been over a month since I have been repeatedly trying to get in touch with the Hospital Authorities for the above said documents but they have been avoiding me for reasons best known to them.


I presume that the hospital authorities have committed a fraud and I would like to file a case regarding the same.


The details of the company are –

Company’s Name: Vardan Nursing Home Pvt Ltd

Company’s Address: Vardan Nursing Home Pvt Ltd, 65 – Jawahar Nagar, Opposite Prakash Hotel, Goregaon West, Mumbai.

Company’s Service Tax No: AACCV2156PSD003

Company’s PAN: AACCV2156P

Company’s Registration No: 887325887


Regards,


Sagar Shinde

Replies